Ibn Qayyim Al-Jawziyya:
If man is able to marry or cohabit then masturbation by hand is haram by him. Aqeel said, "Our leaders (by thought) and companions did not deny masturbation fully i.e. (say it is haram) but expressed the dislike / makrooh label to it. But, they did not explicitly say it is haram." He also said, "If man is not able to marry, and he is tempted to commit adultery, then masturbation is haram by him also."
And the verse (Ayaah) prohibits him from performing masturbation, even if he was not able to resist, or was hesitant between lust and apathy yet there are women to marry and he does not, it is still disliked for him to masturbate and not Haram on him. And if his temptation was overwhelming and he was afraid of hardship as a traveller or prisoner or poor, then it is halal for him (as stated by Ahmad r.a). And it is narrated that the companions used to masturbate during their expeditions and long journeys (it does not refer to the Holy Prophet (saw) about this).
And if a woman had no husband and her temptation grew stronger, it is said by some of our companions that it is permissible for her to behold a 'Akrabanj' (which is made of leather in the shape of man's part) for her to use, or the use of cucumbers or small percussion or what is similar to that.
Source: Bada'i Al-Fuwa'id. Vol. 4, Pg. # 1471 - 1472.
Due to sexual suppression that exists in some of the middle eastern countries, the women have resorted to satisfying their needs in other ways. The issue goes far as clerics issuing rulings prohibiting women from buying bananas and cucumbers!
It appears to be one rule for the men but another for the women. The watermelon has been given a lee-way in all of this, but what crime has the cucumber and banana committed? Even after all this charade, can these people make up there minds? According to the opinion of Muhammad ibn Uthaymeen, such acts are not practiced by Muslims in which case, Bilal Philips, the companions and all those who support Masturbation are not even considered Muslim!
"Rabbi Bilal Philips in the heat of the moment almost confesses to the following:
ReplyDelete@ 20 - 23 seconds he almost says 'I masturbate..'
@ 50 seconds he was almost going to say " I would masturbate"
@ 1 min 20 he almost had a slip of the tongue and said 'speaking from experience'
@ 1 min 35 he thinks about masturbating so much he falsely narrates s Hadeeth of The Prophet says " If one can not fast they they should masturbate"
What an evil liar you are. Seriously, you ought to be ashamed of yourself.
Who is lying about what exactly? "In the heat of the moment almost confesses" no one said he did. So B what is your opinion about masturbation?
ReplyDeleteWell we let people be the judge of that, you need to look up the meaning of the word lying. Your logic amazes me you have a problem accepting the speaker for having masturbated yet your scholars of Hadeeth say the Companions of the Prophet (saw) used to perform it Subhan'Allah!
ReplyDeleteI repeat... you have lied when you claimed that Bilal Phillips was about to say what you claimed. You have no evidence that he was going to say that. So stop lying. Provide your evidence. How do you know what was in his heart? Why won't you humble yourself and admit you are slandering the man and put your arrogance aside?
ReplyDeleteDefinition Of Allude:
ReplyDelete'Suggest or call attention to indirectly; hint at'
I would really recommend you to invest into a dictionary. Both your English and Arabic vocabulary is poor. I have actually done the speaker a favor by suggesting he was alluding to the fact he masturbates after all he would have only been implementing the Sunnah of the Companions. So you call this slander? interesting what Fatwa Ibn Qayyim Al-Jawziyya who said
Quote
"And it is narrated that the companions used to masturbate during their expeditions and long journeys (it does not refer to the Holy prophet about this)... And if woman had no husband and her temptation grew stronger, it is said by some of our companions that it is permissible for her to behold a 'Akrabanj' (which is made of leather in the shape of man's part) for her to use, or the use of cucumbers or small percussion or what is similar to that"
Not only the issue of the companions masturbating you scholars have permitted your women to use dildos! Do you accept Ibn Qayyim Al-Jawziyya was slandering the companions of the Prophet (saw)? Or do you accept the fact the companions used to masturbate but the speaker does no practice this Sunnah?. Do you masturbate? Do your women use Akrabanj?